FHA Manual Underwriting Guidelines
If you are applying for an FHA loan, there is a chance that your application may need to be manually underwritten. FHA manual underwriting guidelines may require additional documentation or compensating factors to secure an approval.
If you believe you need to have manual underwriting for your FHA loan, the good news is there is a good chance you can still get approved for a mortgage.
The key to success when it comes to FHA manual underwriting is working with a loan officer who is experienced in working with difficult files. We have often seen one lender fail at securing a manual underwriting approval while others have great success. It comes with experience and preparing your loan package to the underwriter properly.
We can help you to get approved using manual underwriting. If you would like to speak with someone about your loan scenario, please complete this short form.
What is Manual Underwriting for FHA Loans?
FHA Manual Underwriting is a human review of a mortgage application that may be required when the automated underwriting system (AUS) issues a “Refer/Eligible” finding or when certain risk-based factors exist, such as recent bankruptcy, foreclosure, or higher debt-to-income ratios.
Manual underwriting evaluates compensating factors like cash reserves, employment history, residual income, and verified rent to determine a borrower’s ability to repay.
FHA Manual Underwriting Requirements
Manual underwriting is required when at least one of the following occur:
- The automated underwriting system findings return a “refer” status
- The underwriter downgraded the application to a manual underwrite
- The FHA loan program specifically requires manual underwriting
There are various reasons why the application could require manual underwriting. Some of these reasons may include one or more of the following:
- There is a total of $1000 ore more in disputed derogatory account on the credit report.
- There was a foreclosure, short sale, or deed in lieu within the past three years.
- There was a bankruptcy within the past two years.
- The borrower has had recent late mortgage payments
These are just a few examples and there could be other reasons why your FHA loan application would have to be manually underwritten.
What Will the FHA Manual Underwriter Look For?
The underwriter will be looking for things that can help to approve the loan in the areas of credit, income and assets. The following list of manual underwriting criteria under the HUD Policy Handbook 4000.1 is as follows:
-
Verifying income and employment documentation
-
Credit history review and risk layering
-
Bankruptcy, foreclosure, and seasoning requirements
-
Verification of rent or housing payment history
-
Bank statements for cash reserves
-
Letters of explanation (employment gaps, lates, large deposits)
Explaining in greater detail:
Credit – Low manual UW generally requires minimum ~620 for most lenders, although policy can vary and overlays exist. The underwriter will look at a tri-merge credit report to inspect for dispute, collection or irregular credit activities. If there is not sufficient credit being reported, the underwriter may need to look at non-traditional credit to verify credit worthiness. We can manually underwrite your mortgage even with a 500 credit score.
You should be prepared to provide explanations and help to remove disputes for various accounts. You may also be asked to pay for collection accounts to assist with your FHA loan approval.
If you have late mortgage payments, that will be difficult to overcome and we will instruct you on what you will need to do if you have multiple late payments in the past 12 months.
Income – When analyzing income, the underwriter will determine whether the income is legally derived, documented and likely to continue for the next three years. This will apply to borrowers who are salaried W2 wage earners and those who are self-employed. In addition to the income, the work history will also be reviewed.
Other income sources would need to be verified. These include alimony, child support, overtime, maternity leave, disability, bonuses, and 1099 income just to name a few.
Assets – FHA Manual underwriting guidelines require assets to come from acceptable sources as outlined within the FHA housing policy. The assets will need to cover the down payment, plus all closing costs and any reserves if required.
The underwriter will be looking for checking and savings accounts, gift funds, 401k accounts, down payment assistance, and any other acceptable source.
Final Underwriting – The underwriter must make decisions regarding the loan application that complies with HUD requirements. They will review the appraisal, credit, income and asset documentation to make a final decision on the approval.
The there are compensating factors, they will also be reviewed to help with the analysis.
FHA Manual Underwriting for Bankruptcies
If you have a recent bankruptcy, you may need to have your application manually underwritten for approval.
Chapter 7 Bankruptcy – If you are looking to have an exception to the two year waiting period after a Chapter 7 bankruptcy discharge, you will need to have your file manually underwritten. They will review your reason and any supporting documentation when determining whether an exception can be granted.
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy – You may have the ability to get approved for an FHA loan before your chapter 13 discharge, but after you have made at least 12 on time bankruptcy payments. This will also be manually underwritten.
Read [FHA loan after a bankruptcy]
FHA Manual Underwriting DTI Limits
The FHA loan requirements allow for higher DTI limits up to a maximum of 56.9%. As the DTI increases, the loan application may need to be manually underwritten. In addition, the underwriter may also look for compensating factors with higher debt to income ratios especially when credit scores are lower.
These are examples the FHA compensating factor tiers and maximum DTI ratios, e.g.:
-
31/43 DTI with no compensating factors
-
37/47 DTI with one compensating factor
-
40/50 DTI with two compensating factors
-
40/40 if no discretionary debt exists
Some of these compensating factors may include the following:
- Additional payment reserves
- Job stability
- Little to no payment shock
- A larger down payment
Read [FHA Debt to Income Ratio Requirements]
Compensating Factors Explained
The primary compensating factors underwriters look for when manually underwriting an FHA loan are as follows:
-
Verified cash reserves
-
Minimal housing payment increase (low payment shock)
-
Residual income
- Low DTI
-
Stable employment history
-
Positive prior rent or mortgage payment history
Documents Typically Needed in Manual Underwriting
Prepare yourself in advance to provide some or all of the following documents.
-
Pay stubs & W-2s
-
Bank statements (2+ months)
-
Rent verification or canceled checks
-
Letters of explanation
-
Proof of reserves
The letters of explanation requests may occur after the underwriter first reviews your file. The explanation needed could vary from employment gaps to large deposits in your bank account.
FHA Manual Underwriting – Frequently Asked Questions
What is FHA manual underwriting?
FHA manual underwriting is a loan approval process used when an automated underwriting system cannot issue an approval. Instead of relying on algorithms, a human underwriter evaluates income, credit history, debts, and compensating factors according to HUD guidelines.
When does an FHA loan require manual underwriting?
An FHA loan requires manual underwriting when the automated underwriting system returns a Refer/Eligible or Refer/Caution decision, or when the borrower is in an active Chapter 13 bankruptcy, has no usable credit score, or is using non-traditional credit.
Is FHA manual underwriting harder to get approved?
Manual underwriting is more detailed, but not necessarily harder. Approval depends on strong payment history, stable income, acceptable debt-to-income ratios, and documented compensating factors. Many borrowers qualify when their overall financial profile is solid.
What are the FHA manual underwriting debt-to-income limits?
FHA manual underwriting typically follows these DTI limits:
-
31% front-end / 43% back-end with no compensating factors
-
Up to 37% / 47% with one compensating factor
-
Up to 40% / 50% with two or more strong compensating factors
What counts as a compensating factor for FHA manual underwriting?
Acceptable compensating factors may include verified cash reserves, minimal increase in housing payment, residual income, long-term stable employment, or additional income not used to qualify for the loan.
Can you get an FHA loan during a Chapter 13 bankruptcy?
Yes. FHA allows borrowers to qualify during an active Chapter 13 bankruptcy after at least 12 months of on-time trustee payments, provided the trustee approves the mortgage and the loan is manually underwritten.
Do I need to wait for my Chapter 13 to be discharged?
No. FHA does not require a Chapter 13 discharge to qualify. However, manual underwriting is required until the bankruptcy is discharged.
Can FHA manual underwriting be used with low credit scores?
Yes. FHA allows manual underwriting with credit scores as low as 500, provided the borrower meets down payment requirements, shows acceptable recent payment history, and satisfies HUD underwriting standards.
Can you qualify with no credit score using FHA manual underwriting?
Yes. Borrowers without a credit score may qualify using non-traditional credit, such as documented rent payments, utility bills, insurance payments, and other recurring obligations.
Are collections required to be paid for FHA manual underwriting?
Medical collections are excluded from FHA’s DTI calculations and typically do not need to be paid. Non-medical collections over $2,000 may require a calculated payment, but payoff is not always required unless lender overlays apply.
Are charge-offs required to be paid?
No. FHA does not require charge-offs to be paid as a condition of loan approval, though lenders may impose overlays.
Is rent verification required for FHA manual underwriting?
Yes, in most cases. Manual underwriting typically requires verification of the most recent 12 months of housing payments to demonstrate the borrower’s ability to manage mortgage obligations.
Does FHA manual underwriting require more documentation?
Yes. Manual underwriting involves additional documentation, including detailed income verification, payment history review, housing history, and analysis of compensating factors.
Are interest rates higher on FHA manual underwriting loans?
Not automatically. Rates are based on overall risk factors such as credit score, down payment, and market conditions. Manual underwriting alone does not automatically increase the interest rate.
Can self-employed borrowers use FHA manual underwriting?
Yes. Self-employed borrowers can qualify through manual underwriting as long as income is properly documented and meets FHA stability and consistency requirements.
Is manual underwriting the same as a subprime loan?
No. FHA manual underwriting follows HUD’s guidelines and protections. It is not a subprime loan, even though it may help borrowers with past credit challenges.
Can lenders deny an FHA manual underwriting loan even if HUD allows it?
Yes. Some lenders apply overlays that are stricter than FHA’s minimum requirements. Choosing a lender experienced with FHA manual underwriting is critical.
How long does FHA manual underwriting take?
Manual underwriting may take longer than automated underwriting due to additional documentation and review, but timelines vary by lender and borrower responsiveness.
Can first-time home buyers qualify through FHA manual underwriting?
Yes. First-time buyers frequently qualify using manual underwriting, especially if they have limited credit history but strong income stability and housing payment history.
Is FHA manual underwriting still common?
Yes. FHA manual underwriting is still widely used, particularly for borrowers with Chapter 13 bankruptcies, non-traditional credit, or recent credit recovery.
Summary
If you believe your loan may need FHA manual underwriting, then we can help you. It will be important to work closely with the loan officer, follow their direction, and provide whatever is needed to help with your loan approval.
If you would like to speak with someone about your scenario, please complete this short form and someone will contact you today.
